act legal covers all major European business centres.
Warsaw | Amsterdam | Bratislava | Budapest | Frankfurt | Madrid | Milan | Prague | Vienna
meet us at



The bill of the Usury Act under fire after public consultation  

Michał Sadrak, | 12 January 2017

A majority of organisations and interested entities are critical of the bill prepared by the Ministry of Justice which seeks, among others, to further restrict non-interest costs. The public consultation also covered bonds unfortunately, however, they were contemplated in the context of potential problems with their redemption.

The original version of the document published on government websites contained information from correspondence to officials of the Ministry of Justice, which should not have been included in the document. At the request of relevant parties and after the document had been taken down from the website, we also removed from this communication some quotes taken from the document. The quoted person said during a telephone conversion with that the correspondence the fragments of which had been published on had been placed in a specific context and with a view to calming the situation and not aggravating it.

In general, institutions which decided to express their views during consultation agreed that the market required regulation in terms of unfair practices. At the same time, most of organisations and companies which will be affected if the bill passes stressed that the proposed limit was too strict and too little time had passed from the introduction of the previous limit in order to accurately determine the effects of the previous regulations.

Those who oppose the Usury Act argue, using more or less blunt language, that the entrance into force of the regulations in their current form would increase financial exclusion and cause growth of grey area (which opinion is shared by the National Bank of Poland). It is also argued that unemployment will grow, budget revenue will be reduced and GDP will further suffer on account of decrease in consumption.

Almost 30 entities, which included lending companies, commercial chambers, employers’ federations, law firms, associations (e.g. of notaries public, judges), state credit union or even the Polish Bank Association, participated in the consultation. What is more, seven institutions expressed their opinion during the consultation, including the Polish Financial Supervisory Authority, the National Bank of Poland or the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection. Of course not all positions were equally critical, some of them focused on technical aspects of the bill only.
The issue of debt securities was addressed not only as a source of financing of lending companies. The Chamber of Brokerage Houses suggests that corporate bonds be excluded from the act so that the non-interest costs can be freely shaped. The Chamber of Brokerage Houses reminds that the act on bonds currently in force excludes the application of the provisions on maximum interest to debt interest rates. The Chamber also looked at the issue of security. After the passing of the bill, securities with a value of 150% of the face value of issue would disappear from the market which, in the Chamber’s opinion, could be “catastrophic for the entire debt financing market”.

As part of the public consultation, the issue of bonds, in terms of both costs and securities, was discussed by BSWW Legal & Tax the opinion of which was published on in the middle of December.



Related news


act legal makes its way into Italy

act legal (a European Alliance of law firms) has grown with the joining of VFGS+ (Milan, Italy) in July 2020. act VFGS+ Avvocati is a future-oriented, experienced and dynamic team of lawyers. Its clients include private and public companies, private equity funds and fi...


Mateusz Prokopiuk makes partner at act BSWW

Mateusz Prokopiuk, attorney-at-law, has just joined the group of act BSWW’s partners. He has been with the law firm since 2012. Mateusz specializes in real estate law, real estate transactions (share and asset deals), due diligence audits, mergers, acquisitions and ...


act BSWW to move to new downtown office at Varso Place

act BSWW, one of Poland’s largest law firms and a member of the European act legal group, has leased over 2,000 square meters of the office space at Varso Place, considered among the most modern and prestigious multifunctional developments currently under construction i...


ONLINE COURSE: Register of shareholders and security interests in shares

An online training course on select practical problems from the creditors’ point of view, related to the use of security interests in shares in light of the mandatory dematerialization of shares, will be held on June 30, 2020, from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Participants a...


act BSWW advises Adventum International on purchase of an office building in Wrocław

Adventum International, an investment fund operating internationally, has purchased an office building located at Plac Orląt Lwowskich in Wrocław. Covering a usable area of over 17,000 sq.m., the building (“Centrum Orląt”) is located in a city center of Wrocław, nearby...

Coronavirus alert

Amendments to public procurement law in view of draft “Anti-Crisis Shield 4.0”

A draft version of the so-called “Anti-Crisis Shield 4.0” has just reached the parliament (the “Draft Bill”). It introduces further amendments to the existing special purpose act, including ones that concern the public procurement law (“PPL”). The Draft Bill amends t...

View all